Money-Making Email System: $297 until 30 Nov →
← The blog

Visibility · 18 November 2026 · 8 min read

Is Instagram Worth It for Your Business? How to Tell (and What to Do Instead)

By Kylie Kelly

Is Instagram worth it for your business? Back when I was a wedding photographer I had a beautiful curated feed... but I didn't actually get work from it.

All my jobs came from word of mouth. Referrals. One couple would tell another couple and then another - and I'd often be booked out for months. The Instagram feed was lovely to look at, but it wasn't the thing paying me - at all.

Years later, when I moved my business online, I thought I had to have a beautiful curated Instagram feed to be legit. To really be in business. But one day when I stopped to check the clicks I was getting from my bio through to my website - it was two. TWO. I'm so glad I took the time to stop and look if it was worth it.

So if you're spending hours on Instagram and wondering whether it's worth it for your business, this is how I'd work it out (before you spend another hour, or another dollar on a template pack to fix it!)

Is Instagram worth it? Start with your own numbers

Before anything else, I want to say this: if you love social, if you love Instagram, please you do you. You don't have to stop - but I think it's REALLY important to know that there are other options.

So here's the question I'd ask yourself about Instagram, or about anything else you're currently doing:

Is there an ROI? Is it paying me money? Is it actually paying off?

If you've got all your eggs in one basket, is that basket actually worth it?

And this is the bit I'd really love you to hear. Please don't buy another Instagram course. ACTUALLY look at the data first, and then make a decision about whether it's the best place to spend your time...

Look at the data. Look at the analytics. For me it was the clicks from my bio to my website, and where my last few clients actually came from.

(If you already know the answer and it's not Instagram, I talked through what to build instead of Instagram on the podcast.)

Give it enough time before you decide

Now, one honest caveat. Not every strategy is going to show you results straight away.

Let's say you start Pinterest. That might be 6 months until you start to see results. So make sure you take that into consideration before you call it (and if Pinterest is the one you're curious about, this episode on Pinterest SEO is a good place to start).

The process I keep coming back to is really simple:

  • Go all in.
  • Give it time.
  • Look at the results.
  • Make a decision.
  • Try something else, or continue.

That's it. That's the WHOLE thing.

If you want to get properly into the "is this paying off" side for collaborations, I also had a whole conversation about how to track the ROI of your podcast guest appearances.

If Instagram isn't paying off, here are your other options

This is where it gets fun, because there are SO many options.

I teach it as my V2 framework, and the easiest way to picture it is a capital V.

The relationship side

On one side are the relationship-based strategies. Anything where you're building relationships:

  • summits
  • bundles
  • freebie swaps
  • guest teaching
  • podcast guesting

The search and SEO side

On the other side is search and SEO. That's your long-form content (your podcast, your blog posts), plus YouTube, Pinterest and PR. And social media is still there too.

I've broken the whole thing down in my V2 visibility framework episode if you want to go deeper.

Email is always going to stay dear to my heart, because that's where I love to hang out and it's where I make sales. But it's not enough to just say "create a lead magnet and grow your email list". It's not THAT simple. You need a way for people to actually find you, and that's what these two sides are for.

Pick one lane and go all in

Here's the best part. We don't have to do it ALL.

We get to pick what feels good for us, and where the people we want to help are actually listening or hanging out. Then we go all in on that, and we can just put our blinkers on and not go anywhere else.

Honestly? It's just freeing.

So ask yourself: what feels good for you? Pick ONE. Then work out how you can make it yours... how it becomes your lane, and how you use it to grow your email list.

I've found that everything works, EVERY strategy, even social media. It's about finding what works for you, your business and the people you serve. And we already know more than we think. We know what feels good for us. We know what we want to try.

So just go and try it.

(Full transparency, I have an education folder in my emails full of sh*t I signed up for and never even looked at. We all sign up for things!)

Take the action first, and the confidence follows

A lot of us think that if we just wait, if we make something perfect, we'll feel confident about it and THEN we'll go and do it.

Well, no, no, no.

It's taking the action that gives you data, and the data builds the confidence to then go and follow and listen to yourself, and to build that self-trust. That's the journey. That's the IMPORTANT part.

The reason I've been successful is because I move fast and I take action... f*ck around and see what happens.

So consider this your permission slip to go and take action, look at the data, and then make a decision.

You're allowed to change your mind

Sometimes the data comes back and says no. Sometimes your gut does.

One Black Friday I decided I'd do an offer a day. I got to about the third day and I was like, this is hell. I am not enjoying this at all. So I sent an email out to my list saying I'd made a mistake, here are all the offers on one page, go and have a look, and if you want something, grab it.

I got SO many replies back from people just appreciating that honesty.

I think sometimes we feel like we have to be committed, we have to see things through. You DON'T. You're the business owner. You actually get to make the choice.

That one's personal for me too. After high school I tried to go to university four times to be a teacher, stopping and starting, because I'd grown up being told I never finished anything. And what I've discovered as I've gotten older is that my intuition is WAY more powerful than that old programming of having to finish something.

The same goes for new offers. When I first pivoted I'd create a new offer, like, all the time, and throw it in people's faces... and NOTHING would happen. Don't do that. Once you have your signature offer, the thing you're known for, give it room. I believe offers are like children (they grow up, and they get a life of their own sometimes).

Before you chase new people, connect with the ones you have

If I could add one more thing, it would be this. How can you connect more with the audience you already have?

Whether that's an email list, an Instagram following or your Facebook friends. The people you've worked with in the past. Everyone that's already in your circle.

We often don't think about how to serve the clients who already love and trust us, who've already seen wins, instead of looking for new people all the time. But that's where so much of it is.

How can you add more humanity, more of a human touch, more connection and more depth into your business, wherever your audience is? Information is everywhere now. What people want is to actually do the work and experience what it's like to get something from what you teach.

And we're smart. We know when we're in a funnel and being sold to, and we know if it's bullsh*t or if it's true. If you serve people well, if you treat them well, and if they actually need what you're offering, they will ask to work with you.

So if your numbers tell you Instagram isn't paying off, there's no need to panic. You've got a whole V of options, and the people already in your world are a pretty amazing place to start. (And if growing your list without leaning on Instagram is the bit you want, here's how I'd grow your email list instead.)

Frequently asked questions about whether Instagram is worth it for your business

Is Instagram worth it for a small business?

It can be, if it's actually paying off for you. Ask whether there's an ROI: is it paying you money, is it bringing you clients? If you love it and it works, do it. If you can't see it working, there are plenty of other options.

Should I buy a course to fix my Instagram?

Not before you've looked at your own data. Check what Instagram is actually bringing you first, and then decide whether it's the best place to spend your time.

How long should I try a marketing strategy before I decide?

Long enough to give it a real go. Some strategies take a while (Pinterest, for example, might be 6 months before you start to see results). Go all in, give it time, look at the results, then make a decision.

What can I do instead of Instagram to grow my business?

On the relationship side: summits, bundles, freebie swaps, guest teaching and podcast guesting. On the search and SEO side: a podcast, blog posts, YouTube, Pinterest and PR. You don't have to do them all. Pick the one that feels good for you and go all in.

Is it okay to stop a strategy or a promotion halfway?

Yes. You're the business owner, and you get to make the choice. When I stopped an offer-a-day Black Friday on day three and told my list honestly, I got so many replies from people appreciating it.

Love this post? Save it for later...

Save to Pinterest

your next step...

Make your profile do one job

Break Up With Instagram is my plan for building an Instagram profile that does one job: make the right people want to know more, without you posting every day. It's about finally not needing it to grow your business.

Get Break Up With Instagram →
Kylie Kelly

About the blogger

Hey there...
I'm Kylie Kelly

I'm an ex international wedding photographer turned email marketing educator and the host of The Email Growth Show. I grew my list from 0 to 7,000+ subscribers in 18 months without social media, and I share how, every Friday.

Meet Kylie →

Keep reading