Episode 198 · Solo episode
How I’d Build My Email List From Scratch in 2025 - Without Social Media or Ads
· 14 min listen · 2 min read
About this episode
Imagine it's day one with no list, no audience and no ad budget. I share what I'd ignore completely (daily Instagram posting, generic freebies and ads before anything is validated), then the steps I'd take instead: one strong lead magnet, two or three aligned visibility plays like bundles, podcasts and freebie swaps, a consistent weekly email, and relationships built with care.
The Email Growth Show
Grow your list without social media
EP 198: How I’d Build My Email List From Scratch in 2025 - Without Social Media or Ads
With Kylie Kelly
Start here New to growing your list? Read my full guide: How to Grow Your Email List Without Instagram or Paid Ads → Brand new to email marketing? Start with the beginner’s guide: Email Marketing for Small Business: A Simple Guide to Getting Started →
Listen to the episode
What you'll learn
- Why most “visibility hacks” are just busywork (and what I’d stop doing today)
- The 3 strategic moves I’d focus on if I were starting from scratch
- How to position a lead magnet that actually leads to paid offers
- Why bundles, podcast guesting, and freebie swaps still work in 2025
- The email approach I’d use to build connection from Day 1
- How to build momentum without burning out
Let’s pretend it’s day one.
No email list.
No audience.
No ad budget.
Just a big vision and a deep desire to grow a business that actually feels good to run.
If I were starting again in 2026, I can tell you exactly what I wouldn’t do – and what I’d focus on instead.
Because growth does not need to feel chaotic to work.
What I Would Ignore Completely
Let’s start with what I would not waste my time on.
I would not post daily on Instagram hoping the algorithm finally decides to like me.
I’ve tried it.
You’ve probably tried it.
It’s visibility for the sake of being seen – not connection or conversion.
I would also stop creating generic freebies that attract freebie collectors instead of buyers.
If it’s another “10 tips to…” situation, I’m out.
And I would absolutely not run paid ads before anything is validated.
Ads amplify what’s already working. They don’t create magic.
Step One: Create One Killer Lead Magnet
Not five.
Not a library.
One.
One irresistible lead magnet that does two things:
- Delivers a real transformation
- Naturally leads into your paid work
Think:
- A quiz that positions your expertise
- A case study that tells the truth
- A private audio training that feels intimate
Your free resource should not just teach.
It should position.
Step Two: Choose 2–3 Aligned Visibility Plays
If you want to grow without social media, this is where the magic happens.
I would say yes to 2–3 high-quality visibility opportunities and ignore the rest.
Bundles.
Podcasts.
Freebie swaps.
Inbox collaborations.
Not everything.
Just what’s aligned.
Visibility only works when the right people are paying attention.
And every time I show up, I’d have one clear call to action that leads directly to my email list.
Your list is your home base.
Everything points there.
Step Three: Prioritise Consistency Over Complexity
If I had 23 people on my list, I’d write to them like they were 2,300.
You don’t need funnels stacked on funnels.
You need connection.
One email a week.
Written like a human.
Not a marketer.
My highest-performing emails are never the polished ones. They’re the honest ones.
People don’t want perfection.
They want presence.
Step Four: Build Relationships Like It’s Your Job
Because it is.
Growing without social media turns visibility into a relationship game.
That means:
- Personal podcast pitches
- Thoughtful inbox collaborations
- Following up with gratitude
- Being someone people actually want to support
You don’t need to go viral.
You need to be visible to the right people.
Let’s Recap
If I were building from scratch in 2025, I’d keep it simple:
- One irresistible lead magnet
- Two to three aligned visibility strategies
- One consistent, relationship-led email
- A mindset rooted in connection, not numbers
No dancing.
No ads.
No burnout.
You Don’t Have to Start From Scratch Alone…
If you want to grow your list without ads, algorithms, or burnout, this is the support I offer.
The Email Growth Club is where we build consistent, relationship-led email growth.
The Empress Mastermind is for designing the bigger picture – visibility, offers, and strategy that fit how you actually work.
You don’t need to do everything my love.
You just need to do the right things consistently.
your next step…
Join Email Marketing Skool
It’s my free community for business owners who want to grow their audience, build their email list and create a business that doesn’t rely on feeding the social media machine every bloody day.
Join for free today →Read the full transcript
00:00Kylie Kelly:Let me ask you something. When was the last time you actually enjoyed going through a welcome sequence? Not skimmed, not tolerated? Actually enjoyed it because that question is the reason I stopped sending them. And what I do instead has changed how people engage with my emails completely. Let’s chat about it.
00:22Kylie Kelly:Are you a female business owner frustrated with battling the algorithm and looking for growth strategies that don’t involve awkwardly pointing or dancing online or for growing cash at paid ads? Welcome to the Email Growth Show. I’m your host, Kylie Kelly, visibility and email marketing strategist. I grew my email list from zero to almost 10,000 subscribers in less than two years, and the same is possible for you too.
00:45Kylie Kelly:Are you ready to build your email list and start making more money in your online business? Let’s head into today’s episode.
00:54Kylie Kelly:Hey hey. Welcome back to the Email Growth Show. I am so, so excited that you are here today. We are talking about welcome sequences because I don’t send them anymore. And before anyone panics or thinks I’m saying that they’re dead or useless, that’s not what this is. This is me sharing why they no longer fit, how I want to show up, or how my audience wants to be treated in 2026. And honestly, funnels and sequences just annoy the fuck out of me now. Not because they don’t work in theory, but because my audience is smart.
01:28Kylie Kelly:They know when they’ve entered a funnel. They know when they’re being walked through something step by step. And yes, while I could name it and wink at it and say, yes, welcome to my funnel, I just don’t want to. I don’t want my emails to feel like machinery. I want them to feel like a room that you just walked into. So instead of a traditional welcome sequence, I send one email. Want to know about it? It’s called a Start Here email. Now let’s talk about why I stopped sending them.
01:56Kylie Kelly:Most welcome sequences are built on an old assumption that attention equals readiness. That if someone downloads a freebie, they’re ready to be introduced to your story, educated, nurtured and gently pushed towards an offer within a handful of days. But inbox behavior has changed across email platforms. We’re seeing that open rates are highest on Delivery emails, often 20 to 40% higher than follow up emails in that same sequence. Click rates tend to peak there too. Not email three. Not email five. Not the just checking in email.
02:31Kylie Kelly:The first one, the delivery email. That’s the moment of peak attention. So instead of dragging someone through five or seven emails, hoping they stay engaged long enough to Warm up. I decided to respect that moment. If this is the email they’re most likely to open and actually read, then I want it to do the work. That’s why my start here email replaces the welcome sequence, the orientation emails, the here’s who I am and what I do content. It’s all in one place now. Not sneakily, not manipulatively, just super fucking clearly.
03:04Kylie Kelly:I do want to say funnels aren’t broken, but people are more aware. And I don’t think that coaches or educators, people in the online space are talking about this enough. Funnels used to work really well because people didn’t recognize them. Now they do. Most business owners on your list have either bought multiple courses, joined multiple lists, been through dozens of sequences or funnels. They know the rhythm, they know the pacing, they know when they’re being nurtured. And while awareness doesn’t automatically mean resistance, it does change how people feel. When somebody realizes they’re in a sequence, their nervous system shifts, they skim a bit more, they delay clicking, they wait it out.
03:46Kylie Kelly:Not because they don’t like you, but because they want to regain control. They want to feel safe. Now that’s the part that I care about. I never want my emails to trigger someone’s internal just wait and see response or what she up to response, right. I want them to feel like they’re in control, like they’re choosing to stay so important. Now, if you want to hear a really quick episode about how one of my clients turned off all of her beautiful funnels and actually made three times her monthly revenue within 60 days of working together, go back to episode 230. I’ll link it in the show notes and have a listen. I think if you weren’t sure right now about funnels, that this is really going to bring it home.
04:28Kylie Kelly:The fact that we can turn them off, that you do have options and you can still make the revenue that you are aiming to make, or even more like in Julie’s example now. Now let’s talk about the start here email. What does a start here email actually do? So this is the email that it still delivers, the thing they signed up for. That part matters. So you’re still going to have at the top of that email the link to that free resource or whatever it is that they’ve opted into. But it also answers the questions that every new subscriber has, whether they’re consciously thinking them or not. Who are you really? What kind of emails do you send? How often am I going to hear from you? What do you actually help with? And where should I go if I want more? I don’t drip feed that fcking information over a week. Like no, I give it to them upfront and I let them decide what happens next.
05:17Kylie Kelly:And yes, this email has way more than just one link. And I know that breaks the old rules, but I’m all about breaking rules over here. Those rules come from a time when we assumed people couldn’t make decisions without being guided carefully. From point A to point B. That time is over. My list is full of intelligent women. They’re capable of choosing what’s relevant to them. They don’t need to be funneled down a narrow path like they’ll get overwhelmed by options.
05:43Kylie Kelly:They don’t need to be spoon fed. Giving them choice builds trust. And trust is what converts when they’re ready. Not welcome sequence length. Now listen, here’s what I’m noticing across email lists. Last year and heading into 2026, people aren’t short on information so fucking everywhere, right? They’re short on orientation. They don’t need more emails explaining why email marketing matters. They need to know am I in the right place? Is this person for me? And does this feel safe, calm and relevant? A start here.
06:13Kylie Kelly:Email can answer all of that without pressure. And because it lives in a single reference point, it then can become an anchor. People can save it, bookmark it, come back to it. They can click it when they’re ready. That behavior lines up with what we’re seeing across inboxes. Fewer impulsive clicks, more considered engag. Longer decision cycles, but stronger trust when people do move. So what do I include in my start here email? I will include my full template in the show notes so you can see exactly how I write this.
06:44Kylie Kelly:But conceptually, here’s what it does. I introduce myself like a human. Not a brand bio, not a resume. I set expectations clearly. How often I email, what kind of content I send, what they won’t get from me. That part matters more than people realize. Again, predictability builds safety. Safety builds trust.
07:04Kylie Kelly:Then I give them a few clear places to explore. A free resource that people genuinely love. The podcast. One way to work with me. And I invite conversation. I ask them to reply. I remind them that it’s actually me. I ask them how they found me.
07:19Kylie Kelly:Because email still works best as a two way channel, even if most people never reply. That invitation alone can change how the inbox feels and what they feel when they see my sender name pop up in their inbox next time. So the deeper reason that I do that this way is that it’s more about tone, right? A welcome sequence often says, sit down, I’ll take you through this. A start here. Email says, oh my gosh, welcome, you’ve arrived, you’re here, let me show you around, take what you need. Can you feel the difference there? That matters. It tells your subscriber that they’re not a number, that they’re not a lead, that they’re not something to be warmed up before they’re allowed to choose. They get agency from the very first email and in my experience that creates better long term engagement than any perfectly timed sequence ever could.
08:09Kylie Kelly:Now, if you’re thinking of trying this, if you’ve been feeling resistance around welcome sequences, or maybe you don’t even have one set up yet, no shade if your emails feel heavier than they used to, if you want your inbox to feel more human, this is a simple experiment worth running. You don’t need to burn everything down, you don’t need to overthink it. You just need to write one email that does the job. All you need to do, turn off your welcome sequences, put up this one email, track it for 30 days. Obviously get people onto your list to receive the thing, track it for 30 days and see. See how it feels. See what the data tells you, see what the responses are like. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed.
08:49Kylie Kelly:Now, like I said, I’ll put my full start here template in the show notes. You can adapt it for your own voice, your own offers, your own people. I’m so excited for you to try this and I want to know if this episode sparks something or if you want help simplifying how your emails actually work together. You know exactly where to find me, my loves. That is it for today. I hope you enjoy this. I hope you feel inspired to create your own start here email and ditch the welcome sequence if it is no longer serving you and your ideal clients. Reach out if you have any questions.
09:19Kylie Kelly:I love you loads and I will talk to you really soon, like really soon. I’ve got some really good stuff coming your way and next week’s episode is our guest episode with an incredible, incredible PR expert. You’re going to want to tune in. All right, I will see you then. Bye for now. Thank you so much for tuning into.
09:37Kylie Kelly:This episode of the Email Growth Show. I hope you found valuable insights into the next steps you can take to grow your email list and boost your business without relying on social media or paid ads. If you enjoyed this episode, please take a moment to rate and review the.
09:51Kylie Kelly:Show and share it with others. Your feedback helps me reach more female.
09:55Kylie Kelly:Entrepreneurs just like you who are ready to say goodbye to social media and leverage email marketing to grow their business and make a bigger impact.
10:03Kylie Kelly:Thank you so much for listening and.
10:04Kylie Kelly:I’ll see you in the next episode.
Free · for every new episode
Grab the one sheet takeaways.
Podcasts are so easy to listen to and so much harder to act on afterwards. So every new episode gets its own cheat sheet: one page, with the key points, ready for when you finally sit down to do the thing.
More to listen to
The Email Growth Show
Grow your list without social media
EP 262: Instagram Isn’t Working? Grow Your Email List Like This Instead
With Kylie Kelly
The Email Growth Show
Grow your list without social media
EP 209: How I Got 135 Leads in 30 Days From One Quiz - Without Paid Ads
With Kylie Kelly
The Email Growth Show
Grow your list without social media
EP 201: How Allison Hardy Grew Her Email List from 4K to 10K Without Ads or Social
With Kylie Kelly
Listener questions
Got a question for the show?
Record it in your own voice. I may answer it on a future episode.